Maestro (2005)

While Maestro might have its technical achievements, it suffers from the short format’s most constant blight: being merely a visual joke. Some of the visual gags within the film are chuckle-inducing, but overall, the film is a disappointment, because once the overall punchline is revealed, that’s about it. There’s simply one level to the film, and thus, it leaves little to ponder when the credits roll.

Now, this is not to say the setup and payoff were ineffective, because I was amused when the joke came to fruition. I’d go into more detail about it, but if I were to spoil this one element, you’d literally have no reason to see the film, as there’s nothing else to it. At first I thought the technical elements might be enough for it to work on multiple levels, but the constant jolting camera movement got old fast, and there’s nothing particularly unique about the look of the film, given that 95% of all animated movies these days (short or feature length) have the same overall texture and feel. I don’t know if I’d have gone so far as to give it an Oscar nomination, but I guess one has to give it credit for setting out to tell a joke, and succeeding at getting to the punchline.

-Mark Moreland


 

Home  ·   ThoughtsOn Awards   ·   About   ·   Index (A-Z)

All contents © 2004-2009 Thoughtsonfilm.com


Director: Géza M. Tóth
Writer: Géza M. Tóth
Starring: Ákos Ambrus, Imre Madácsi, Attila Pacsay
Distributor: Magnolia Pictures
Runtime:
5 min
Rating:
Not Rated
Release Date:
February 16, 2007

  Oscar Nominee:  Short Film-Animated

IMDb
Buy the DVD


Fandango  - We've Got Your Movie Tickets!