No Country for Old Men · Miramax 

Scott's Top 10 of 2007

It's a strange year when my annual top film list contains no documentaries, two musicals and my favorite working filmmaker released a movie that didn't make my cut. Ah well, Wes Anderson's loss is The Mist's gain. Enjoy!

Honorable Mention: Hot Fuzz, Sunshine

10. The Mist: Stephen King's love letter to H.P. Lovecraft produced a gripping feature and one of the most enjoyable times I had in a theater this year. It also captured very succinctly the culture war presently raging in partisan America.

9. 3:10 to Yuma: There was a time when the Western was king but after Sputnik the zeitgeist shifted, almost permanently, away from the past and towards Sci-fi. Yuma's a fantastic modern Western that reminds you how good the genre can be.

8. The Great Debaters: Screenwriter Julius Epstein once said of Casablanca that the script was filled with "more corn than in the states of Kansas and Iowa combined, but when corn works, there's nothing better." The same could be said for The Great Debaters. Obvious and corny though it may be, it's a very moving film.

7. Before the Devil Knows You're Dead: The characters are unlikable. The message, that crime doesn't pay, is simplistic bordering on childish, but the film is gripping and proof that a movie doesn't need to be glossy or whitewashed to be entertaining.

6. Juno: A PG-13 movie in which two sixteen-year-old girls casually discuss having an abortion and that a friend of theirs already has had one—… we've come a long way, baby. But more than reflecting the modern political landscape, Juno is funny, warm and enjoyable.

5. Michael Clayton: I just kept thinking about it. At first I thought it was too theatrical to make my list, but the more I reflected on the movie the more I liked it. That's always a great sign the movie will have longevity (if no where else than certainly on my DVD shelf).

4. Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street:I don't ordinarily like musicals yet I have two not only in my top ten, but top five… Sweeney Todd struck such an amazing balance between being atmospheric and energetic it was impossible not to enjoy. And though it goes without saying that Depp is an amazing actor, that's a shame, because he truly is an absolutely fantastic actor. He's been doing it for so long that we almost forget about how noteworthy his performances are.

3. Persepolis: Persepolis is so deeply personal you feel as though you've known Marjane Satrapi her whole life. Further, and most importantly, Persepolis accurately reflects that Iran (specifically and the Muslim world in general) is comprised of individuals who oppose and support one another in a fluid myriad of ways and that these individuals aren't all in lockstep behind any one person or ideology, which is something we can easily lose sight of in our media when mostly all we hear is, "Terrorists in Iraq have been linked to Iran," and the various grotesqueries of Mahmoud Ahmadinejad. 

2. Once: Once is what independent film should be. Once is what independent film can be. A small story, beautifully told. Ambiguous and haunting.

1. No Country for Old Men: The Coen Brothers at their worst are still better than 99.99% of all other film makers, still it was nice to see them shake things up a little bit. As much as I love their more comedic offerings, they seemed to be running out steam of late. No Country gave them a much needed shot in the arm.




Home
  ·   ThoughtsOn Awards   ·   About   ·   Index (A-Z)

All contents © 2004-2009 Thoughtsonfilm.com
 

Other Years' Awards
1st Annual Awards (2006)
2nd Annual Awards (2007)
3rd Annual Awards (2008)

THE BEST OF 2007
Critics' Top 10 Lists

Alison Anderson
Danielle Ní Dhighe
Robert Foster
Scott Kline
Mark Moreland